Welcome to Upper Crust Pizza
Upper Crust Pizza, located in Key Largo, FL, has been a beloved spot for over 20 years, known for its delicious pizza and garlic rolls. Customers rave about the friendly staff, great beer selection, and tasty Italian dishes like lasagna and chicken parm. The casual atmosphere is perfect for hanging out or grabbing a quick meal to-go. Reviewers especially appreciate the flavorful toppings and attentive service. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pizza or exploring new tastes, Upper Crust Pizza is sure to satisfy your cravings with their savory offerings.
Upper Crust Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Pizza was OK. Service was OK. The pizza tasted good but the crust was kind of soggy.
We had a 16" meat lovers & a 16" sausage. Excellent food! We had it delivered to the Caloosa campground. Service was as fast and food was hot!
Sorry no pizza pics. We wanted to grab some pizza for back at our hotel and upper crust came highly recommended. Rightfully so. We popped in and grabbed some wine (only pic I took) while we waited for our pizza. The atmosphere was fun, the staff chatted with us a lot while we waited, and the wine was good enough to grab a second round while waiting. Once the pizza was ready we settled up and headed back to the hotel. The pizza was still great cold. We just got a basic pizza, but it was done well. The two of us are the whole thing and wished we had grabbed some others to try. If you're in the area and want a nice place to hang out or just want to grab and go like we did, you won't go wrong at Upper Crust.
I've been coming to Upper Crust for over 20 years. Their pizza and garlic rolls never disappoint.
Typically we get pizza from here... which is great. But recently we have gotten lasagna and chicken parm... we absolutely loved it! The gravy is perfect... rich and delicious! Cheese bubbly and cooked to perfection. The staff is very friendly and we always welcome the warm hello and conversation. Oh...and last but not least...they have the best beer selection in the keys!!
Summing it up, this was a very good night out. We had the 14" Chillax Pizza which was enough for two people with leftovers. The Chillax is like a new and improved Hawaiian pizza. Pineapple, bacon, red peppers, onion, pepperoncini. The only downfall was the crust which I would rate a 4/5. Our server (possibly Emelia) was great. Very attentive and gave drink suggestions. The vibe that we loved was the way the staff bantered with locals as they came in.
We've been in Key Largo. FL fir a month, and this is the absolute best Pizza that we've had. Looking forward to going back for more.... They have several other dinners that we look to trying.
Location
-
101611 Overseas Hwy Key Largo, FL 33037 Hotline: (305) 451-4188
Located in Key Largo, FL, Upper Crust Pizza is a hidden gem offering a variety of delectable Italian pizzas. With options for delivery, takeout, and reservations, this casual restaurant caters to all preferences.
Customers rave about the flavorful pizzas and friendly service at Upper Crust Pizza. Jennifer M. describes the food as excellent, with hot and fast delivery to the Caloosa campground. Christopher S. highlights the fun atmosphere and great wine selection, while Isabel A. has been a loyal patron for over 20 years enjoying the consistently delicious pizza and garlic rolls.
Not just known for their pizzas, Ellen B. praises their lasagna and chicken parmigiana, complementing the rich gravy and bubbly cheese. Additionally, the staff's warmth and the impressive beer selection make Upper Crust Pizza a must-visit spot in the Keys.
My experience at Upper Crust Pizza was nothing short of delightful. The aroma of freshly baked pizzas filled the air, and each bite was bursting with flavor. The staff's attentiveness and the cozy ambiance made for a memorable dining experience. I can confidently say that Upper Crust Pizza lives up to its reputation as a go-to spot for quality Italian cuisine.
